Best AI college essay feedback tools 2026: an honest comparison

We make Halo. Here is how the tools compare, with sources.

This page does not rank the tools. Halo is listed first because we wrote the page; the rest are in alphabetical order. Every cell comes from the company’s own site.

AI college essay feedback tools side by side

AI college essay feedback tools side by side
ToolWhat it doesScores?Line feedback?Writes text for you?Free tierPaid price
HaloA writing workspace for every college essay, with school-specific rubric scoring, school research and a deadline calendar.Yes. A score out of 100, with a score and a written reason for each rubric dimension.Yes. Line-by-line notes, plus a ranked list of what to fix first.Coaches without ghostwriting. Polish and trimming suggest small edits you accept or reject.2 full essay analyses per account, in total, plus unlimited essays in the workspace. No credit card.Premium $100 a month.Source: haloadmit.com/pricing
CoGraderA free grader that scores a college essay against a five-criterion admissions rubric: central message, authentic voice, reflection and insight, concrete detail, meaningful topic.Yes, against that rubric, weighted by essay type. The numeric scale: not listed on their site.Yes. Its page says each score links to the specific lines that need work.No. Says it does not rewrite.Free to use. The page shows "3 free grades remaining", and the first essay needs no signup.Not listed on their siteSource: cograder.com/college-essay-grader
collegeessaygrader.comCredit-based scoring and critique of college essays. A different site from CoGrader.Yes. Its pricing page advertises an instant AI score and critique.Not listed on their siteNot listed on their site. Its FAQ talks about students rewriting and re-grading their own drafts.No free tier on its pricing page.Credit packs, from $9.99 for 10 credits up to $149.99 for 400 credits.Source: collegeessaygrader.com/pricing
EssloFeedback on Common App, supplemental, Coalition, UC and UCAS college essays.Yes. Scores across six categories, plus a percentile against the 150,000+ scored essays Esslo says it has.Yes. Line-by-line comments on what to cut, keep or rewrite.No. Esslo says it never drafts any part of a student's essay.1 round of feedback on one draft.$40 a month (students applying to fewer than 4 schools, up to 20 drafts a month), $80 a month (unlimited essays), $100 a month (whole application: essays plus an activities list with scored feedback). Fee-waiver students can request free unlimited access.Source: esslo.org/pricing, esslo.org/llms.txt
GradGPTEssay reviews with comments and a score on each draft.Yes. Its pricing page lists a score on every draft.Yes. Its pricing page describes "exact lines to fix".No. Its pricing FAQ says GradGPT does not write essays for you.One free essay review. Students who qualify can ask for free access by email.Plus $36 a month (50 reviews a month). Max $96 a month (unlimited reviews and a library of 1000+ T20 admitted essays). Or one payment for the season through February 2027: $144 (Plus) or $243 (Max).Source: gradgpt.com/pricing
GradPilotRubric review of an essay against the prompt you pick: Common App, UC, supplemental and transfer essays, plus graduate, medical and law school essays.Full Review: a score per rubric area. Quick Review: critiques, no scores.Full Review: critiques tied to passages. Whether Quick Review is line-level: not listed on their site.No. Its site says "You write the words."A free account gets 2 Quick Reviews a day. No scores on the free tier.First Full Review $5. Pro $50 for 10 Full Reviews. No subscription.Source: gradpilot.com, gradpilot.com/college-essay-ai-checker
GrammarlyA general grammar, clarity and tone checker with AI prompts that can generate and rewrite text.No essay score is listed on its plans page, and no admissions rubric.Suggestions on grammar, clarity and tone.Yes. Its AI prompts can generate and rewrite text.100 AI prompts a month.Pro lists $12 USD (billing period not confirmed) with 2,000 AI prompts per member per month.Source: grammarly.com/plans
KollyCollege essay review with notes and rewrites, plus an accepted-essay library and a scholarship finder.Yes. The free review includes a score.Notes on the essay. Whether they are line-level: not listed on their site.Yes. The free review includes a rewrite, and the monthly plan includes paragraph rewrites.One full essay review (score, notes and rewrite) and 3,000 credits. No credit card.$29 a month for unlimited essay reviews and paragraph rewrites. Season Pass $99 for 6 months, renewing every 6 months.Source: kolly.ai/pricing
Next AdmitA standalone free grader for college essays.Yes. An overall score out of 100, plus five category scores (richness, insight, voice, authenticity, mechanics).Yes. Shows your strongest and weakest lines and flags 10 to 15 phrases.No. Says it never writes replacement text.Three free grades per month. No account needed for the first essay; an email is asked for to send the results link.Consultant essay review is offered. Price: not listed on their site.Source: nextadmit.com/college-essay-grader, nextadmit.com/.../methodology

Checked November 3, 2026.

How we checked

On November 3, 2026 we read each company’s own pricing or product page and wrote down only what it states. "Not listed on their site" means we could not find that detail there; it does not mean the tool lacks it.

Where a roundup or directory disagrees with a company’s own page, we used the company’s page. Free tiers and prices change, so check the linked page before you pay.

We left out tools whose own pages did not let us confirm what they offer today, for example Kollegio. "Writes text for you" asks one thing: does the tool produce sentences or paragraphs of your college essay.

The tools, one at a time

Halo

Halo is a college application workspace, so grading is one part of a larger tool: you write each essay there and research schools and plan deadlines beside it. Drafts are scored out of 100 against the rubric for the school and prompt, with line-by-line notes. The free plan includes 2 full essay analyses per account; Premium is $100 a month. Halo coaches you without ghostwriting. You get scoring and school-specific feedback, but every word stays yours: your voice, never ours. Polish and word-count trimming suggest small edits, such as fixing a grammar error or cutting a redundant phrase. Every change lands as an edit you accept or reject.

CoGrader

CoGrader is a free grader that scores a college essay against a five-criterion admissions rubric and says it does not rewrite. Its page shows "3 free grades remaining", and the first essay needs no signup. Its page says each score links to the specific lines that need work. The numeric scale is not listed on their site.

collegeessaygrader.com

collegeessaygrader.com sells credit packs rather than a subscription, from $9.99 for 10 credits. Its pricing page lists no free tier, and its FAQ describes using credits to grade, rewrite and re-grade a draft until the score improves. Whether the tool itself writes text for you is not listed on their site. It is a different site from CoGrader.

Esslo

Like Halo, Esslo gives a score and line-by-line comments and says it never drafts any part of a student’s essay. Its free tier is one round of feedback on one draft, and paid plans run from $40 to $100 a month. Students with a fee waiver can request free unlimited access. Esslo’s site is esslo.org.

GradGPT

GradGPT sells monthly review plans: Plus at $36 a month for 50 reviews, and Max at $96 a month for unlimited reviews and a library of 1000+ T20 admitted essays. It has one free essay review, and students who qualify can ask for free access. Its pricing page lists a score and "exact lines to fix". Its pricing FAQ says GradGPT does not write essays for you.

GradPilot

GradPilot is pay-as-you-go instead of a subscription. A free account gets 2 Quick Reviews a day, which give critiques without scores. A Full Review adds a score per rubric area and critiques tied to passages; the first costs $5, and Pro is $50 for 10. Its site says "You write the words."

Grammarly

Grammarly is a general writing tool, not an admissions tool. It checks grammar, clarity and tone, and its AI prompts can generate and rewrite text. The free plan has 100 AI prompts a month; Pro lists $12 USD with 2,000 prompts per member per month, and the billing period is not confirmed on the plans page. Its plans page lists no admissions rubric or essay score.

Kolly

Kolly’s free review includes a score, notes and a rewrite, so it does write text for you, and its monthly plan includes paragraph rewrites. It also has a library of accepted essays and a scholarship finder. It costs $29 a month, or $99 for a six-month Season Pass that renews every six months.

Next Admit

Next Admit is a standalone free grader. It gives an overall score out of 100 and five category scores, shows your strongest and weakest lines, and flags 10 to 15 phrases. The free tier is three grades a month, and the first essay needs no account. It says it never writes replacement text. It also offers consultant essay review; the price is not listed on their site.

Which one fits what you need

A score without making an account first
Next Admit and CoGrader both say the first essay needs no account or signup.
Paying per review, not by subscription
GradPilot ($5 for the first Full Review, $50 for 10) and collegeessaygrader.com (credit packs from $9.99).
A tool that does not write your essay
Esslo and Next Admit say they never draft or write replacement text, CoGrader says it does not rewrite, GradGPT says it does not write essays for you, and GradPilot says "You write the words." Halo coaches without ghostwriting.
A tool that rewrites for you
Kolly and Grammarly both say they can rewrite text. Decide first whether you want a tool that writes text.
Writing, school research and deadlines in one place
Halo is built as a workspace. Esslo’s $100 plan also adds an activities list with scored feedback.
A fee waiver
Esslo lists free unlimited access for Common App, SAT or ACT fee-waiver students by request form. GradGPT says students who qualify can email for free access.

Try Halo on your own college essay

A free account includes 2 full essay analyses: a score out of 100 and line-by-line notes. No credit card.