What do essays that worked actually score?
A score in the 70s can feel like a failing grade. We ran six college essays that Johns Hopkins and Hamilton College published as examples of essays that worked through Halo's scoring. We scored three of the essays Hamilton publishes. They scored between 74 and 87 out of 100, with an average of 80.3. None reached 90.
The six scores
| College | Essay | Score out of 100 | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Johns Hopkins University | Clean Closet | 79 | Read it on the college's site: Clean Closet |
| Johns Hopkins University | Developing Roots | 74 | Read it on the college's site: Developing Roots |
| Johns Hopkins University | In the Belly of the Ship | 85 | Read it on the college's site: In the Belly of the Ship |
| Hamilton College | A Hamilton essay (87) | 87 | Read it on the college's site: A Hamilton essay (87) |
| Hamilton College | A Hamilton essay (80) | 80 | Read it on the college's site: A Hamilton essay (80) |
| Hamilton College | A Hamilton essay (77) | 77 | Read it on the college's site: A Hamilton essay (77) |
Each essay was scored once, on 2026-11-06, against the Common App personal statement.
What the high scores had in common
For each essay, this is one strength Halo noted, next to the line it points to. Each note is about one specific detail or line.
It's packed with favorite toys, plush animals, retired gymnastics leotards, and grandma-sewn dresses that once decorated my childhood.
Halo, on Specificity: "Grandma-sewn dresses" and "retired gymnastics leotards" are the kind of details that sound like one real person.
Not only are they larger than any other tree species, but they have also evolved a thick, fire-resistant bark allowing growth to continue even after a ravaging fire in their ecosystem.
Halo, on Specificity: Real botany, correctly used. The fire-resistant bark detail does work for you. It sets up resilience as the quality you're claiming. This is the nerdy, specific voice that makes you sound like you.
A net around my cot attempted to keep out the mosquitos, and the room's thin walls leaked every crewman's cough.
Halo, on Specificity: 'Leaked every crewman's cough' does two jobs. It's sensory, and it plants your central tension: you're surrounded by people and still alone. Nothing generic here.
Whether it was the pulsing LED lights or the poker-faced judge, he stopped, launching me forward over the fence and into the cold, sandy arena floor.
Halo, on Language & Craft: 'Poker-faced judge' and 'pulsing LED lights' are sharp, specific, and slightly funny. The sentence also lands the fall with real momentum. This is the voice you want in a personal statement.
I looked like an extra in an apocalypse movie; I felt like one too.
Halo, on Voice & Authenticity: This sounds like a real teenager, wry and self-aware, and it makes the illness land without self-pity. The humor earns the reader's trust. This is the voice of someone who can laugh at himself, and that carries the whole essay.
It was the first and only time I visited the Sunshine State, but I never made it to pristine beaches or Disney.
Halo, on Voice & Authenticity: Good opener. The deflated-vacation joke sounds like a real person, and it sets up the 'this was serious business' turn without announcing it.
Three of the six strongest notes are about specificity, two are about voice and one is about the craft of a single sentence. In the scores, specificity earned the largest share of its available points.
Where even these lost points
These are the average scores for each rubric dimension across all six essays, using only the dimension scores from the run.
| Dimension | Points possible | Average score | Average points short |
|---|---|---|---|
| Voice & Authenticity | 14 | 11.8 | 2.2 |
| Specificity | 14 | 12.3 | 1.7 |
| Insight & Reflection | 14 | 10.7 | 3.3 |
| Structure & Flow | 7 | 6.0 | 1.0 |
| Language & Craft | 3 | 2.2 | 0.8 |
| Character Revelation Through Action & Conflict | 23 | 17.0 | 6.0 |
| Thematic Coherence | 15 | 12.0 | 3.0 |
| Narrative Arc & Scene-Setting | 10 | 8.0 | 2.0 |
Character Revelation Through Action & Conflict is the biggest weight in the rubric, 23 of the 100 points. It is also where the six gave up the most: 17.0 out of 23 on average, 6.0 points short, more than on any other dimension.
The plain advice that follows: show one real moment rather than a label. Name what you did, where, and what happened next, instead of telling the reader what kind of person you are.
How to read your own score
A 74 is in the same range as an essay a college published. The lowest of these six was 74, and three of the six landed in the 70s.
This is six essays scored once. A score can move between runs of the same essay, and no score predicts admission. Treat your number as feedback on this draft: where it is strong, and which dimension to work on next.
See where your essay lands
Free to start with 2 scores. Halo never writes your essay.
Essays belong to their authors and the colleges that published them. Scored on 2026-11-06 with the Common App personal statement rubric. Halo is not affiliated with Johns Hopkins or Hamilton.